Malicious Prosecution in Ghana: Elements, Relevant Cases and Legal Remedies

Malicious prosecution in Ghana is a tort that allows a person who has been wrongfully subjected to criminal proceedings to seek compensation where the legal requirements are satisfied.However, an acquittal does not automatically entitle a person to damages. The claimant must establish that the defendant initiated or was actively instrumental in bringing about the prosecution, that the proceedings terminated in the claimant’s favour, that there was no reasonable and probable cause, that the defendant acted maliciously, and that the claimant suffered damage.

This article explains the five essential elements of malicious prosecution, the leading Ghanaian cases, the evidence required to prove a claim and the legal remedies that may be available.

1. What Is Malicious Prosecution?

Malicious prosecution is a civil wrong committed where a person improperly sets criminal proceedings in motion against another person without reasonable and probable cause and with malice, and the proceedings terminate in favour of the person prosecuted, causing legally recognised damage.

The tort protects individuals against the misuse of criminal proceedings for purposes such as personal revenge, intimidation, reputational harm or the pursuit of private disputes through criminal allegations.

At the same time, the law recognises the public interest in allowing people to report suspected crimes honestly and in good faith. A person who reports a genuine suspicion should not ordinarily be liable simply because the authorities subsequently prosecute the accused and the case fails.

The distinction is between a genuine complaint made on reasonable grounds and the deliberate or otherwise legally wrongful use of criminal proceedings against another person.

2. The Five Elements of Malicious Prosecution in Ghana

The Supreme Court in Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII[1963] 1 GLR 182 (SC) identified the essential requirements of an action for malicious prosecution. These requirements were also discussed in Soadwah alias Sondura and Others v Obeng and Others [1966] GLR 338–351 (SC).

The claimant must establish all five elements:

1. The defendant instituted the prosecution or was actively instrumental in setting the law in motion against the claimant.

2. The criminal proceedings terminated in the claimant’s favour.

3. The defendant acted without reasonable and probable cause.

4. The defendant acted maliciously.

5. The claimant suffered damage as a result of the prosecution.

Failure to prove any one of these elements may defeat the claim.

Case authorities: Yeboah v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182and Soadwah v Obeng [1966] GLR 338.

3. Element One: The Defendant Must Have Instituted or Instigated the Prosecution

The first requirement is that the defendant must have initiated the prosecution or been actively instrumental in putting the criminal law in motion against the claimant.

This does not necessarily mean that the defendant personally appeared in court as the prosecutor. In Ghana, criminal prosecutions are generally conducted under the constitutional authority of the Attorney-General. Nevertheless, a private individual may be liable where their conduct amounts to instituting, procuring or actively instigating the prosecution.

Examples may include knowingly making a false criminal complaint and actively procuring a prosecution, deliberately supplying false information that causes the authorities to charge another person, or commencing a private prosecution on a knowingly false factual basis.

Whether the defendant legally initiated the prosecution depends on the facts and the degree of their involvement.

Soadwah alias Sondura and Others v Obeng and Others [1966] GLR 338–351 (SC)

This is one of the leading Ghanaian authorities on the first element of malicious prosecution.

The appellant reported to the police that his house had been broken into and his personal property stolen. His complaint was based on information supplied by his son and uncle. The police investigated the allegation, and the respondents were subsequently prosecuted for stealing. They were acquitted and discharged and later, the respondents sued for malicious prosecution.

At trial, the judge found that the appellant had been instrumental in setting the law in motion. On appeal, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal because the evidence showed that the police had initiated the prosecution in the exercise of their own discretion.

The Court distinguished the mere provision of information to the police from actively instigating a prosecution.

The principle is that a person who makes a genuine complaint and leaves the police to investigate independently will not ordinarily be liable merely because the police subsequently prosecute the accused.

However, a complainant who actively procures proceedings through deliberate falsehoods or other wrongful conduct may be liable if the remaining elements are also established.

Citation: Soadwah alias Sondura and Others v Obeng and Others [1966] GLR 338–351 (SC).

Read the judgment

Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182–194 (SC)

The appellants were involved in a customary dispute concerning the payment of dues. Following customary arbitration, they were required to make pacification payments. They subsequently complained that the respondent, a paramount chief, had extorted money from them.

The police declined to prosecute because they considered that the complaint disclosed no criminal offence. The appellants nevertheless pursued a private prosecution. The Attorney-General later entered a nolle prosequi, and the respondent brought an action for malicious prosecution.

The Supreme Court upheld the finding of liability. The circumstances supported the conclusion that the appellants had pursued a criminal allegation despite knowing that the payments arose from customary proceedings.

The case demonstrates that a person cannot necessarily avoid liability by claiming that a lawyer advised them to prosecute. The court may examine whether the defendant disclosed all material facts to the lawyer before obtaining that advice.

The decision also illustrates how a private individual may be actively instrumental in initiating criminal proceedings even though the actual prosecution is conducted by a lawyer or public prosecutor.

Citation: Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182–194 (SC).

Read the case report

4. Element Two: The Proceedings Must Have Terminated in the Claimant’s Favour

The second element requires the claimant to establish that the criminal proceedings have terminated in their favour.

A claimant cannot ordinarily bring a completed action for malicious prosecution while the relevant criminal proceedings remain unresolved. The effect of the termination must be assessed under the applicable law and in light of the circumstances of the particular case.

A favourable termination may include an acquittal or a discharge that legally satisfies the requirement. The effect of a discontinuance or other procedural termination must be considered carefully.

Acquittal

An acquittal ordinarily satisfies the requirement that the proceedings terminate in favour of the accused.

Article 19(2)(c) of the 1992 Constitution of Ghana provides for the presumption of innocence: a person charged with a criminal offence is presumed innocent until proved or has pleaded guilty.

However, an acquittal does not, by itself, establish that the complainant acted maliciously or without reasonable and probable cause. Those elements must be proved separately.

Discharge of the accused

A discharge may constitute a favourable termination depending on its legal basis and the circumstances in which it was ordered.

For example, a discharge following a failure by the prosecution to establish a sufficient case may satisfy the requirement, subject to the applicable procedural rules.

The claimant should obtain the court’s order and relevant proceedings to establish precisely how the criminal case ended.

Termination by nolle prosequi

A nolle prosequi is a formal discontinuance of criminal proceedings by the Attorney-General under the applicable law.

In Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182 (SC), the Supreme Court accepted that an entry of nolle prosequicould constitute a termination in favour of the accused for purposes of a malicious prosecution action.

The decision addressed the earlier uncertainty reflected in Goddard v Smith and Gilchrist v Gardiner, with the West African Court of Appeal having preferred the reasoning in the latter case in Malek Khoury v Tabbara.

The important point is that a nolle prosequi may satisfy the termination requirement. It does not, however, automatically prove that the defendant committed malicious prosecution.

Case authority: Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182–194 (SC).

5. Element Three: The Prosecution Must Have Been Without Reasonable and Probable Cause

The third element requires the claimant to prove that the defendant lacked reasonable and probable cause for initiating the prosecution.

This requirement protects people who honestly report suspected crimes on reasonable grounds, even where the allegations later prove unsuccessful.

The inquiry concerns the defendant’s state of belief and the objective reasonableness of the grounds on which the prosecution was initiated.

The court considers the circumstances known to the defendant at the relevant time, rather than deciding the question solely by reference to the eventual acquittal.

Hicks v Faulkner (1881) 8 QBD 167

In Hicks v Faulkner, the court explained the meaning of reasonable and probable cause in the context of a prosecution for perjury.

The plaintiff had testified in a dispute concerning rent and the return of keys to rented premises. The defendant believed that the plaintiff had lied under oath and initiated proceedings for perjury. The plaintiff was acquitted and subsequently sued for malicious prosecution.

Hawkins J explained that reasonable and probable cause requires an honest belief in the accused person’s guilt based on reasonable grounds and circumstances that would lead an ordinarily prudent and cautious person to the same conclusion.

The principle involves two related questions:

1. Did the defendant honestly believe that the claimant was probably guilty of the alleged offence?

2. Were there reasonable grounds for that belief, assessed objectively in the circumstances?

A genuinely held belief may still be unreasonable if it lacks an adequate factual basis. Conversely, the fact that a prosecution fails does not necessarily mean that the defendant lacked reasonable and probable cause.

Citation: Hicks v Faulkner (1881) 8 QBD 167 at 171.

Applying the principle in Ghana

In Soadwah alias Sondura and Others v Obeng and Others[1966] GLR 338–351 (SC), the Supreme Court considered the significance of the information supplied to the police and their independent investigation.

The case illustrates that the failure of the prosecution does not, without more, establish the absence of reasonable and probable cause. The circumstances in which the complaint was made and the conduct of the person responsible for initiating proceedings must be examined.

In Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182–194 (SC), the appellants pursued an allegation of extortion despite the circumstances showing that the payments arose from customary proceedings. Their failure to disclose material facts to their legal adviser was also relevant.

The case demonstrates that reliance on legal advice does not automatically establish reasonable and probable cause where the advice was obtained on the basis of incomplete or misleading information.

6. Element Four: The Defendant Must Have Acted Maliciously

Malice concerns the defendant’s motive for initiating the prosecution.

It may involve spite, ill will, a desire to injure the claimant or another improper purpose inconsistent with the proper pursuit of justice.

A claimant must establish malice on the evidence. It is not enough to show that the prosecution failed or that the claimant was acquitted.

Evidence that may be relevant includes threats to use criminal proceedings to punish the claimant, deliberate fabrication of allegations, concealment of material facts, or persistence in prosecuting despite knowledge that the factual basis for the charge is false.

The court evaluates the circumstances as a whole. No single circumstance necessarily establishes malice.

Glinski v McIver [1962] AC 726 (HL)

In Glinski v McIver, the House of Lords examined the relationship between malice and the absence of reasonable and probable cause.

The decision emphasises that these are separate elements. Although malice may, in appropriate circumstances, be inferred from an absence of reasonable and probable cause, the latter must be established independently and cannot simply be inferred from the existence of malice.

The distinction is important because a person may act from hostility while nevertheless having reasonable grounds to report suspected criminal conduct. Equally, a person may lack reasonable grounds without necessarily acting from a malicious motive.

The court must therefore consider both the objective basis for the prosecution and the defendant’s actual motive.

Citation: Glinski v McIver [1962] AC 726 (HL).

Applying the principle in Yeboah v Boateng VII

In Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182–194 (SC), the appellants pursued an allegation of extortion arising from customary pacification payments.

The circumstances supported the conclusion that the appellants knew the material facts surrounding the payments but nevertheless pursued a criminal allegation. Their conduct and failure to disclose relevant facts to counsel were important to the court’s assessment.

The case illustrates that malice may be inferred from the evidence surrounding the institution of proceedings, but it must be considered separately from the absence of reasonable and probable cause.

7. Element Five: The Claimant Must Prove Damage

Malicious prosecution is not actionable per se. This means that the mere fact that a person has been prosecuted and acquitted does not automatically entitle that person to damages.

The claimant must prove legally recognised damage resulting from the prosecution.

The traditional categories of damage are traced to Savile v Roberts (1698) 1 Ld Raym 374:

1. Damage to reputation.

2. Injury to the person, including loss of liberty.

3. Financial loss or damage to property.

The claimant must provide evidence of the relevant harm and establish its connection with the prosecution.

Damage to reputation

A criminal allegation may damage a person’s professional standing, business relationships or reputation in the community.

Relevant evidence may include testimony from people who know the claimant, proof of lost business opportunities, employment consequences and other circumstances demonstrating reputational harm.

Loss of liberty or personal injury

Arrest or detention associated with a prosecution may cause loss of liberty and other personal harm.

Evidence of the circumstances and duration of detention may be relevant. Medical records may also support claims involving physical or psychological injury.

Financial loss

Financial damage may include loss of employment, lost business income or other demonstrable financial consequences attributable to the prosecution.

The claimant should preserve relevant documents, receipts, employment records, accounts and other evidence supporting the claim.

Musa and Another v Limo-Wulana and Another [1975] 2 GLR 290–301 (CA)

In Musa v Limo-Wulana, the defendants complained that the plaintiffs had unlawfully fished in a village dam. The plaintiffs were arrested and prosecuted for nuisance but were subsequently acquitted and discharged.

They brought an action for malicious prosecution. The Court of Appeal restated the essential requirements of the tort and held that the action failed because the plaintiffs had not led evidence to establish damage.

The case demonstrates that even where proceedings terminate in the claimant’s favour, the claim may fail if the claimant does not prove the damage required by law.

Citation: Musa and Another v Limo-Wulana and Another[1975] 2 GLR 290–301 (CA).

Read the case report

8. Can Malicious Prosecution Apply to Civil Proceedings?

Malicious prosecution ordinarily concerns criminal proceedings. However, the common law has recognised a limited category of exceptional civil proceedings that may support an action in circumstances analogous to malicious prosecution.

Quartz Hill Consolidated Gold Mining Co v Eyre (1883) 11 QBD 674 (CA)

In Quartz Hill Consolidated Gold Mining Co v Eyre, a shareholder presented a winding-up petition against a company in circumstances alleged to be malicious and without reasonable cause.

The Court of Appeal recognised that a malicious and groundless winding-up petition could support an action in circumstances where the proceedings were inherently damaging to the company’s credit and reputation.

The decision does not establish that every unsuccessful civil claim can give rise to an action for malicious prosecution. It concerns a limited exception involving particular proceedings with consequences analogous to a criminal prosecution.

Citation: Quartz Hill Consolidated Gold Mining Co v Eyre(1883) 11 QBD 674 (CA).

9. The Role of the Attorney-General under Article 88 of the Constitution

Article 88 of the 1992 Constitution provides the constitutional foundation for the Attorney-General’s responsibility for criminal prosecutions in Ghana.

Article 88(3) provides that the Attorney-General shall be responsible for the initiation and conduct of all prosecutions of criminal offences. Article 88(4) addresses the exercise of prosecutorial functions by persons authorised by the Attorney-General.

This constitutional framework explains why a private complainant does not ordinarily conduct a public prosecution simply by reporting an alleged offence.

However, a private person may be liable for malicious prosecution where their conduct satisfies the legal requirements for instituting, procuring or actively instigating proceedings.

The court must examine the actual role played by the defendant rather than assume that the person who made the complaint is necessarily the prosecutor.

The Attorney-General’s constitutional powers must also be distinguished from the separate question of civil liability. Whether a public official or public authority may be liable in a particular case depends on the applicable law, the official’s conduct and the relevant legal protections.

10. Evidence Required to Prove Malicious Prosecution

A claimant should gather evidence capable of establishing each of the five elements.

Court records: Charge sheets, court proceedings, judgments, acquittal orders, discharge orders and documents recording the termination of the prosecution.

Police records: Complaint records, witness statements, investigation reports and other admissible evidence showing what the defendant reported and how the authorities responded.

Communications: Letters, emails, messages and other communications that may demonstrate threats, false allegations, concealment of material facts or an improper motive.

Witness testimony: Evidence from persons who witnessed relevant events or can explain the circumstances surrounding the complaint and prosecution.

Financial records: Payslips, business records, invoices and other documents demonstrating financial loss attributable to the proceedings.

Medical evidence: Medical reports and related records where the claimant alleges physical or psychological injury.

Evidence concerning legal advice: Relevant evidence showing what information was supplied to a lawyer and whether material facts were concealed or misrepresented.

The claimant must ensure that the evidence is relevant and admissible. An acquittal alone does not prove all the elements of the civil claim.

11. How to Bring an Action for Malicious Prosecution in Ghana

A person considering an action should take the following steps.

Step 1: Obtain the criminal case records

Collect the relevant court records and documents establishing how the proceedings began and how they ended.

Step 2: Identify the person legally responsible

Determine whether the proposed defendant merely reported the allegation or actively instigated, procured or initiated the prosecution.

Step 3: Establish the absence of reasonable and probable cause

Identify the information available to the defendant when the prosecution was initiated and the evidence demonstrating why the decision lacked reasonable and probable cause.

Step 4: Gather evidence of malice

Identify communications, conduct or surrounding circumstances that support the allegation of an improper motive.

Step 5: Document the damage suffered

Gather evidence of reputational harm, loss of liberty, personal injury or financial loss attributable to the prosecution.

Step 6: Obtain legal advice

A lawyer can assess the evidence, identify the appropriate defendant, determine the applicable procedural requirements and advise on the available remedies.

Step 7: Commence proceedings where justified

If the evidence supports the claim, proceedings may be commenced in the appropriate court in accordance with the applicable procedural rules and limitation periods.

A claimant should seek legal advice promptly because the applicable limitation period must be verified before proceedings are commenced.

12. Remedies Available for Malicious Prosecution

Where a claimant establishes malicious prosecution, the court may award damages according to the nature and extent of the proven loss.

Depending on the evidence and applicable law, the remedies may include:

General damages: Compensation for legally recognised harm, including reputational injury and other non-pecuniary loss.

Special damages: Compensation for specific financial losses that are properly pleaded and proved.

Other appropriate relief: Any additional remedy available under the applicable law and justified by the circumstances.

The amount awarded depends on the evidence, the nature of the harm and the applicable legal principles. A successful claim does not guarantee a particular sum.

13. Summary of the Leading Cases

CaseCitationLegal principle
Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII[1963] 1 GLR 182–194 (SC)Five essential elements, reasonable and probable cause, malice, nolle prosequi and legal advice.
Soadwah alias Sondura and Others v Obeng and Others[1966] GLR 338–351 (SC)Mere reporting of suspected crime distinguished from actively instituting or instigating a prosecution.
Hicks v Faulkner(1881) 8 QBD 167Meaning of reasonable and probable cause.
Glinski v McIver[1962] AC 726 (HL)Malice and absence of reasonable and probable cause are separate elements.
Musa and Another v Limo-Wulana and Another[1975] 2 GLR 290–301 (CA)Damage must be proved; acquittal alone is insufficient.
Savile v Roberts(1698) 1 Ld Raym 374Traditional categories of damage.
Quartz Hill Consolidated Gold Mining Co v Eyre(1883) 11 QBD 674 (CA)Limited exception involving malicious institution of winding-up proceedings.

Conclusion

Malicious prosecution is an important civil remedy against the wrongful use of criminal proceedings. However, it is not a remedy for every person who has been arrested, charged or acquitted.

A claimant must prove that the defendant was legally responsible for initiating or instigating the prosecution, that the proceedings terminated in the claimant’s favour, that there was no reasonable and probable cause, that the defendant acted maliciously and that legally recognised damage resulted.

The Ghanaian Supreme Court decisions in Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII and Soadwah alias Sondura and Others v Obeng and Others remain particularly important in understanding these requirements. The decision in Musa v Limo-Wulana also demonstrates why evidence of damage is indispensable.

Anyone who believes they have been subjected to malicious prosecution should preserve the relevant court records, police documents, communications and evidence of loss, and obtain legal advice on the merits and procedural requirements of a potential claim.

Disclaimer: This article provides general legal information and is not a substitute for advice on the facts of a particular case. The full judgments and current Ghanaian law should be consulted before relying on any authority in litigation.

References and Case Reports

1. Soadwah alias Sondura and Others v Obeng and Others[1966] GLR 338–351 (SC)

2. Yeboah and Others v Boateng VII [1963] 1 GLR 182–194 (SC)

3. Musa and Another v Limo-Wulana and Another [1975] 2 GLR 290–301 (CA)

4. Hicks v Faulkner (1881) 8 QBD 167

5. Glinski v McIver [1962] AC 726 (HL)

6. Quartz Hill Consolidated Gold Mining Co v Eyre (1883) 11 QBD 674 (CA)

7. Constitution of the Republic of Ghana, 1992

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Consult a Lawyer

If you want to get a consultation without any obligations, fill in the form below and we will get in touch with you.