ACTION FOR CONVERSION OF GOODS IN GHANA: Meaning And Legal Remedies

By Seth Doe, Esq.

Introduction

The law protects individuals and businesses against the wrongful taking, use, sale, detention or disposal of their personal property. Where a person deals with another person’s goods in a manner that seriously interferes with the rights of the person entitled to possess them, the conduct may amount to the tort of conversion.

Conversion is particularly relevant to commercial transactions involving vehicles, machinery, imported goods, business stock, equipment, furniture and other movable property.

In Ghana, an action for conversion may be brought by a person who has the necessary ownership or possessory rights against a person who wrongfully exercises control over the goods. The claimant may seek damages and, where legally available, an order for the return or delivery of the goods.

1. What Is Conversion?

In ordinary language, conversion means changing something from one form to another. However, in tort law, conversion has a different meaning.

Conversion is the intentional dealing with goods in a manner inconsistent with the rights of the owner or another person entitled to immediate possession of those goods.

It occurs where a person exercises control over another person’s goods in a way that amounts to denying or seriously interfering with the claimant’s rights.

For example, if A lends B a laptop for one week and B subsequently sells the laptop to C without A’s authority, B may be liable for conversion because the sale is inconsistent with A’s rights over the laptop.

Conversion does not necessarily require physical damage to the goods. A person may commit conversion by selling, transferring, appropriating or otherwise dealing with goods as though entitled to exercise ownership over them.

2. Examples of Conversion

The distinction between conversion and trespass to goods is important.

  • A motor vehicle: Sitting on another person’s car without permission may amount to trespass to goods, depending on the circumstances. Selling that car without the owner’s authority may amount to conversion.
  • A laptop: Unauthorisedly pressing keys or touching another person’s laptop may constitute trespass to goods. Taking the laptop and selling it without authority may constitute conversion.
  • A textbook: Writing on another person’s textbook without permission may constitute trespass to goods. Deliberately tearing out substantial pages or destroying the book may amount to conversion if the interference is sufficiently serious and inconsistent with the owner’s rights.
  • Imported goods: A carrier or warehouse operator who unlawfully redirects or sells a customer’s goods instead of delivering them to the rightful recipient may commit conversion.
  • Business equipment: A person who takes another business’s machinery and incorporates it into their own operations without authority may be liable for conversion.

The decisive issue is not simply whether the defendant touched or damaged the goods. The court examines the nature and seriousness of the interference and whether it was inconsistent with the claimant’s right to possession.

3. Essential Elements of Conversion

To establish an action for conversion, a claimant generally needs to prove the following:

A. Identifiable goods

The claim must concern identifiable personal property, such as a vehicle, laptop, machinery, furniture, business stock or other movable goods.

Conversion concerns personal property, not land itself.

B. Ownership or a right to immediate possession

The claimant must establish ownership or another legally recognised right to immediate possession of the goods at the relevant time. A person who possesses goods lawfully may sometimes sue even without proving absolute ownership.

C. Deliberate dealing with the goods

The defendant must have engaged in deliberate conduct involving the goods. The claimant does not necessarily need to prove that the defendant knew the conduct was unlawful or intended to cause harm.

D. Interference inconsistent with the claimant’s rights

The defendant’s conduct must be sufficiently inconsistent with the claimant’s rights to amount to conversion. Examples include unauthorised sales, wrongful transfers, destruction, appropriation or detention accompanied by conduct denying the claimant’s right to the goods.

E. Absence of lawful authority or justification

The dealing must be wrongful. Conduct authorised by the owner, permitted by a valid contractual right or justified by law will not ordinarily amount to conversion.

The claimant must establish the elements required by the particular circumstances and the applicable law. Proof of actual financial loss is not always necessary to establish liability, although the nature and amount of damages will depend on the facts.

4. Important Cases on Conversion

A.

Fouldes v Willoughby

(1841) 8 M & W 540

In this case, the claimant boarded a ferry with two horses. Following a disagreement, the defendant, who managed the ferry, removed the horses from the vessel and placed them on shore. The claimant crossed the river without the horses and subsequently brought an action for conversion.

The court distinguished the removal of the horses from an act amounting to conversion. The mere removal of a chattel, without an intention to exercise ownership or dominion over it inconsistently with the claimant’s rights, did not necessarily constitute conversion.

The case establishes that not every unauthorised movement of goods amounts to conversion. The nature of the defendant’s conduct and whether it was inconsistent with the claimant’s possessory rights must be examined.

B.

Kuwait Airways Corporation v Iraqi Airways Co (Nos 4 and 5)

[2002] 2 AC 883 (HL)

This is an important English authority on conversion.

Following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait in 1990, Iraqi forces seized aircraft belonging to Kuwait Airways Corporation. The aircraft were taken to Iraq, and subsequent actions were taken to incorporate them into Iraqi Airways’ fleet. These included registering the aircraft in Iraqi Airways’ name, repainting them and using them commercially.

The House of Lords explained that conversion can arise in different circumstances and identified three general features of the tort:

  1. The defendant’s conduct was inconsistent with the rights of the owner or another person entitled to possession.
  2. The conduct was deliberate rather than accidental.
  3. The interference was sufficiently serious to exclude the person entitled to the goods from their possession or use.

The case demonstrates that conversion is not limited to physically taking goods away from their owner. A defendant may commit conversion by exercising dominion over goods in a manner that denies the claimant’s rights.

The House of Lords also considered questions of state immunity and the effect of the Iraqi government’s actions. Those issues formed part of the wider dispute, but the case is particularly significant for its explanation of conversion.

C.

Youngdung Industries Ltd v Roro Services and Others

[2006] GHASC 4, reported at [2005–2006] SCGLR 816

This Ghanaian Supreme Court decision concerned goods entrusted to a carrier in connection with an import transaction. The dispute involved the handling and re-consignment of the goods without proper authority.

The Supreme Court considered the principles governing conversion and the distinction between conversion and wrongful detention. The case is an important Ghanaian authority on the consequences of dealing with another person’s goods inconsistently with that person’s rights.

The decision also addressed the assessment of damages. In a conversion claim, the ordinary measure is generally the value of the goods at the relevant date of conversion, together with consequential loss that is legally recoverable and not too remote, subject to the circumstances of the case.

The case is particularly relevant to businesses, importers, carriers and persons responsible for holding or transporting goods. A carrier’s or warehouse operator’s possession of goods does not, by itself, authorise the person to sell, redirect or otherwise dispose of them contrary to the rights of the person entitled to possession.

D.

T.K. Serbeh & Co Ltd v Mensah

[2005] GHASC 21

In this Ghanaian Supreme Court decision, the Court considered a dispute involving goods that had been sold without the relevant authority. The case addressed when conversion occurred and the assessment of damages.

The decision supports the principle that an unauthorised sale may constitute conversion because it is an exercise of control over the goods inconsistent with the rights of the person entitled to them.

It also illustrates that the claimant must provide appropriate evidence of the value of the goods when seeking substantial damages. The court’s assessment cannot simply be based on an unsupported assertion of value.

E.

Penfolds Wines Pty Ltd v Elliott

(1946) 74 CLR 204

Penfolds Wines supplied wine in bottles bearing its name. The company retained ownership of the bottles under its arrangements with purchasers. Elliott, an hotelier, filled empty Penfolds bottles brought to him by customers with wine from his own supplies.

The court considered whether Elliott’s conduct amounted to conversion of the bottles. The case illustrates the importance of examining whether the defendant’s dealings with goods actually interfered with the claimant’s immediate right to possession.

It is a useful comparative authority for distinguishing conversion from other forms of interference with goods. Its application must be considered alongside the relevant Ghanaian law and the particular facts of a dispute.

5. Conversion, Trespass to Goods and Wrongful Detention

These concepts are related, but they are not identical.

Trespass to goods generally involves direct and unlawful interference with goods in another person’s possession. For example, deliberately moving or handling another person’s vehicle without permission may constitute trespass to goods.

Conversion involves a more serious interference with the rights of the person entitled to possession. Selling another person’s vehicle without authority is a typical example.

Wrongful detention concerns the unlawful retention of goods that another person is entitled to recover. Depending on the facts and applicable law, the conduct may amount to conversion or support another recognised claim for recovery of the goods.

A demand for the return of goods followed by refusal can provide evidence of conversion where the circumstances demonstrate an intention to exercise control over the goods inconsistently with the claimant’s rights. However, a demand and refusal are not the only means of proving conversion. An unauthorised sale or other clear act of appropriation may itself establish the necessary interference.

Forson v Koens and Another

[1975] 2 GLR 479

In this Ghanaian case, a purchaser had possession of a motor vehicle after making part payment. The seller arranged for a soldier to seize the vehicle publicly, although the agreement did not authorise the seizure in the circumstances.

The court treated the seizure as trespass to goods. The case illustrates that a person’s interference with another’s possession of a vehicle may be actionable even where the dispute concerns payment or ownership arrangements.

The case is particularly useful for understanding the distinction between trespass to goods and conversion: trespass protects possession against direct unlawful interference, while conversion focuses on dealing with goods in a manner inconsistent with the rights of the person entitled to possess them.

6. Who Can Bring an Action for Conversion?

A person bringing an action for conversion must establish a legally recognised right to the goods at the time of the interference.

This may include:

  • An owner who has the right to immediate possession.
  • A person in actual possession who has a legally protected possessory interest.
  • A bailee or another person entitled to immediate possession under a relevant arrangement.
  • A person with a reversionary interest where the interference has damaged or destroyed that interest in circumstances recognised by law.

Absolute ownership is not always essential. In Armory v Delamirie (1722) 1 Strange 505; 93 ER 664, a finder of a jewel was permitted to assert possessory rights against a person who wrongfully dealt with it, despite the finder not being able to establish absolute ownership.

However, a person who owns goods but has temporarily transferred possession to another may not always have an immediate right to sue for conversion. The nature of the claimant’s interest and the legal effect of the interference must be examined.

7. Defences to an Action for Conversion

A defendant may seek to resist a claim by establishing a recognised defence or showing that the claimant has not proved an essential element.

Possible arguments include:

  1. Consent or authority: The claimant authorised the relevant dealing with the goods.
  2. Superior right to possession: The defendant had a better immediate right to possess the goods.
  3. Lawful seizure or detention: A statute, court order or other lawful authority permitted the relevant conduct.
  4. Lien or contractual right: The defendant was legally entitled to retain the goods to secure payment or performance of an obligation.
  5. No conversion: The defendant’s conduct did not amount to an interference sufficiently inconsistent with the claimant’s rights.
  6. Lack of a possessory right: The claimant did not have the ownership or right to immediate possession required to bring the action.
  7. Limitation: The claim was commenced outside the applicable limitation period.

The availability of a defence depends on the particular facts and the applicable law. For example, a debt owed by a customer does not automatically authorise a carrier or service provider to sell that customer’s goods.

8. Remedies for Conversion

A person who successfully establishes conversion may seek appropriate relief from the court.

A. Damages for the value of the goods

The ordinary measure of damages is generally the value of the goods at the date of conversion. The court considers the evidence of value and the circumstances in which the wrongful dealing occurred.

In Youngdung Industries Ltd v Roro Services and Others [2006] GHASC 4, the Supreme Court addressed the assessment of damages in the context of the wrongful handling of goods.

B. Consequential loss

A claimant may also seek damages for additional loss caused by the conversion, provided the loss is legally recoverable, sufficiently connected to the wrongful conduct and not too remote.

For example, a business may seek compensation for certain additional expenses caused by the wrongful conversion of machinery, subject to the applicable legal requirements and proof.

C. Return or delivery of the goods

Where the goods remain available, the claimant may seek an order for their return or delivery where that remedy is legally available and appropriate. The court will consider the nature of the claim, the claimant’s rights and the applicable procedural rules.

D. Interest and costs

The court may award interest and costs in accordance with the applicable law and circumstances.

The appropriate remedy depends on the claimant’s rights, the availability of the goods, the nature of the interference and the evidence of loss.

9. How to Bring an Action for Conversion in Ghana

A person who believes their goods have been converted should consult a lawyer to assess the claim and the appropriate remedy. The lawyer will generally:

  1. Identify the goods and establish the claimant’s ownership or right to immediate possession.
  2. Gather purchase receipts, invoices, delivery notes, contracts, registration records, photographs and other evidence identifying the goods.
  3. Establish how the defendant took, sold, transferred, retained, destroyed or otherwise dealt with the goods.
  4. Examine any possible consent, contractual authority, lien or other legal justification.
  5. Assess the value of the goods and any additional loss that may be recoverable.
  6. Send a letter of demand where appropriate, requesting return of the goods, cessation of the interference or compensation.
  7. Consider settlement or urgent interim relief where there is a risk that the goods may be sold, concealed, transferred or destroyed.
  8. If necessary, prepare and file proceedings in a court with the appropriate jurisdiction, setting out the relevant facts, legal basis and remedies sought.
  9. Present the necessary evidence and comply with the applicable court procedures.

The lawyer should also consider limitation periods, the correct parties to the action and whether conversion, trespass to goods, wrongful detention or another cause of action best fits the facts.

Conclusion

Conversion protects the rights of persons entitled to possess goods against deliberate dealings that seriously interfere with those rights. It may arise where goods are wrongfully sold, transferred, appropriated, destroyed or otherwise dealt with as though the defendant were entitled to exercise ownership over them.

The decisions in Fouldes v Willoughby, Kuwait Airways Corporation v Iraqi Airways Co, Youngdung Industries Ltd v Roro Services and Others and T.K. Serbeh & Co Ltd v Mensah illustrate important principles concerning the nature of conversion, the distinction between conversion and other forms of interference with goods, and the assessment of damages.

For individuals and businesses in Ghana, the essential lesson is to preserve evidence of ownership or the right to possession, document the defendant’s conduct and seek legal advice promptly where goods have been wrongfully dealt with.

This article is for general legal information and does not constitute legal advice on any particular dispute.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Consult a Lawyer

If you want to get a consultation without any obligations, fill in the form below and we will get in touch with you.