ACTION FOR PRIVATE NUISANCE IN GHANA: Law, Cases And Remedies
Seth Doe Esq.
Private nuisance is a tort that protects a person’s use and enjoyment of land against substantial and unreasonable interference by another person. In Ghana, an affected property owner or other person with a legally recognised interest in the land may seek damages or an injunction where the interference amounts to an actionable nuisance.
Common examples include excessive noise, offensive smells, smoke, dust, vibrations and activities that substantially interfere with the peaceful enjoyment of neighbouring property.
1. Essential Principles of Private Nuisance
To establish private nuisance, a claimant generally needs to show:
- Interference: The defendant’s conduct interferes with the use or enjoyment of the claimant’s land or causes physical damage to it.
- Substantiality: The interference is sufficiently serious and is not merely a minor inconvenience.
- Unreasonableness: The court considers the nature, intensity, frequency, duration and timing of the interference, together with the character of the neighbourhood.
- Responsibility: The defendant created, continued or adopted the nuisance, or is otherwise legally responsible for it.
The central question is whether the interference goes beyond what a person should reasonably be expected to tolerate in the circumstances.
2. Important Ghanaian Cases and the Principles They Establish
A. C.F.C. Construction Company v Accra City Council
Citation: C.F.C. Construction Company & Others v Accra City Council [1964] GLR 496 (HC). <Cite refs={[“turn197654search1”,“turn197654search2”]}/>
Facts: The Accra City Council dumped refuse in an open quarry close to the plaintiffs’ residential estate at Tesano, Accra. The refuse produced offensive and pestilential smells and vapours that interfered with the residents’ comfort and enjoyment of their homes. The Council argued, among other things, that its activities were authorised by statute.
Decision and principle: The High Court held that the smells and vapours constituted an actionable nuisance. The statutory provisions relied upon by the Council did not authorise it to create a legal nuisance, and the Council had acted unreasonably by dumping refuse close to residential properties without adequate precautions.The court also recognised that an interference may be actionable even if it is temporary, provided it is sufficiently serious.
Legal principle: A public authority is not automatically protected from liability for nuisance merely because it is performing public duties. Statutory authority must extend to the activity complained of, and reasonable precautions must be taken where applicable.
B. Aidoo v Adjei and Others
Citation: Aidoo v Adjei & Others [1976] 1 GLR 431
Facts: The case concerned a dispute over land at Jukwa, including a residence and structures used in connection with a chop bar. The reported case addresses both land ownership and the nuisance arising from the operation of the chop bar.
Decision and principle: The case is reported as an authority concerning actionable nuisance arising from a chop bar operating next to a dwelling. The particular nuisance principle should be read alongside the full judgment before relying on it for a detailed proposition about noise, food fumes or vibrations.
Legal principle: Activities conducted on land must be assessed in light of their effects on neighbouring occupiers; a commercial use of property does not automatically excuse an actionable interference.
C. Mrs Patricia Bannerman and Dr Elizabeth Masopeh v International Central Gospel Church, Cross Road Community Church Ministries and the Municipal Chief Executive
Citations: Suit No. AP 56/2014, High Court (General Jurisdiction 1), Accra, judgment delivered 21 January
Facts: The plaintiffs lived in Haatso, Accra, where they sought a peaceful residential environment. Two churches subsequently conducted activities involving loud singing, clapping, drumming, amplified music and prayers, including at night and on weekends. The plaintiffs complained that the noise substantially interfered with their enjoyment of their homes. Environmental measurements recorded noise levels of approximately 76–86 dB(A) at one plaintiff’s house.
Decision: The High Court found that the activities of both churches amounted to private nuisance. It awarded GH¢20,000 in damages against each church and made orders concerning compliance with environmental requirements. The court also made a separate damages award against the Municipal Chief Executive in connection with the handling of the matter.
The court declined to order demolition or complete cessation of the church activities, taking account of the circumstances, including changes to the area’s zoning.
Legal principles:
- Private nuisance involves balancing the right of one occupier to use their property against a neighbour’s right to its peaceful enjoyment.
- Reasonableness is central to liability, and the character and suitability of the locality are relevant.
- An activity that benefits the community is not automatically justified if it causes serious interference with a neighbour’s enjoyment of property.
- The nature of the activity, its intensity and its effects must be assessed in the circumstances of the case.
This is a particularly useful Ghanaian authority for disputes involving excessive noise from churches, entertainment venues and other establishments near residential properties.
3. Other Important Common-Law Authorities
D. Christie v Davey
Citation: Christie v Davey [1893] 1 Ch 316 (Ch).
Facts: The claimant gave music lessons at home. Her neighbour deliberately banged on walls, beat trays and made other noises to disrupt the lessons in retaliation for the music.
Decision: The court granted an injunction restraining the neighbour’s disruptive conduct.
Principle: Deliberate and malicious interference intended to annoy a neighbour may constitute nuisance. The fact that a person is using their own property does not give them an unrestricted right to interfere unreasonably with another’s enjoyment of land.
E. Bamford v Turnley
Citation: Bamford v Turnley (1862) 3 B & S 66; 122 ER 27 (Exch Ch).
Facts: The defendant burned bricks in a kiln, producing fumes that affected neighbouring occupiers.
Principle: The law seeks to balance the ordinary and reasonable use of property against the rights of neighbours. Whether an activity amounts to nuisance depends on all the circumstances, including the nature and extent of the interference and the character of the locality.
F. Sedleigh-Denfield v O’Callaghan
Citation: Sedleigh-Denfield v O’Callaghan [1940] AC 880 (HL).
Facts: A pipe and grating on the defendants’ land became blocked during heavy rain, causing water to escape and flood the claimant’s land. The defendants’ servant knew of the arrangement and the risk.
Decision and principle: An occupier may be liable for continuing a nuisance created by another person where the occupier knows, or ought to know, of the nuisance and has a reasonable opportunity to take steps to remedy it.
4. Who Can Sue and Who Can Be Sued?
A claimant generally needs a legally recognised interest in the affected land, such as ownership or a qualifying leasehold interest. Mere physical occupation, without the necessary legal interest, may not be sufficient to bring an action for private nuisance.
In Malone v Laskey [1907] 2 KB 141, the claimant failed because she lacked the requisite proprietary interest in the property.
A claim may be brought against the person who creates or continues the nuisance. Under the principle in Sedleigh-Denfield v O’Callaghan [1940] AC 880, an occupier who knows of a nuisance and fails to take reasonable steps to address it may also be liable in appropriate circumstances.
5. Remedies for Private Nuisance
The principal remedies are:
- Damages: Compensation for the actionable interference and any recoverable loss established by the claimant.
- Injunction: A court order restraining the continuation of the nuisance or requiring appropriate measures to address it.
- Abatement: Limited self-help to remove a nuisance where legally permitted, subject to the applicable restrictions.
The remedy depends on the evidence, the seriousness of the interference and the circumstances of the case.
Conclusion Private nuisance protects the reasonable use and enjoyment of land. The leading Ghanaian authorities discussed above demonstrate that excessive noise, offensive smells and other serious disturbances may give rise to liability where they unreasonably interfere with neighbouring property.
A person experiencing persistent nuisance should document the interference, establish their interest in the affected land and obtain legal advice on the appropriate remedy.
This article provides general legal information and is not a substitute for advice on a specific dispute.
Categories
- Agreements and Transactions
- Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
- Business Entities and Investment
- Commercial Law
- Company law and Corporate Governance
- Constitutional law
- Contract Agreement
- Contract Templates
- Copyright Law
- Criminal Law
- Cybersecurity and Data Privacy
- Family Law
- Human Rights
- Intellectual Property
- Land Law
- Law School
- Legal Education
- Licensing and Regulatory Framework
- MURDER
- Property and Real Estate
- Tort Law and Civil Wrongs
- Trespass to Land


